• 0 Posts
  • 5 Comments
Joined 7 months ago
Cake day: March 14th, 2025
  • Luc@lemmy.worldtoAsk Lemmy@lemmy.world•Is it racist to oppose illegal immigrants?
    1·
    6 days ago

    Does unrestricted immigration work?

    I’m not aware that any country (that anyone would want to go to, not like a war zone) has completely free immigration. I’d be opposed to having no more borders from one day to the next for the simple reason that it’s a big change. One that’s worth trialing and working towards, of course, but not something we can yet know will work afaik. Especially if we’re the first country doing this and 2 billion people decide the Netherlands would be a fine place to live in (it is!). I’d not be surprised if it turns out we need a lottery kind of system, or maybe an announcement system, at least for those not in mortal danger, so that we can build living spaces ahead of time. Supply and demand is currently such that the only way to afford a house (even for top, idk, ~2% of world incomes) is to have a house so you can sell it at the inflated price, and while immigration is afaik a net positive to a country’s wealth and welfare, this effect is offset in time. The housing crisis will pass again, as it always has, but in general the solution should be sustainable and I’m not aware that it’s as simple as “be in favor of unrestricted immigration or else you’re a racist”

  • Luc@lemmy.worldtoAsk Lemmy@lemmy.world•Immigrants in most countries are required to pledge allegiance to their adopted country to become exempt from deportation (aka: Attaining Citizenship Status); What do you think of this practice?
    2·
    6 days ago

    Why does the netherlands do so many things well

    I’m really curious about this also! What makes some nations be, ehm, in a “sensible” state (in my eyes) and others not, given similar situations and options? We’re by no means as cool as Iceland or Finland for example, eyeing metrics like happiness index and development index, but why not?

    Being a small population and/or region seems to be a part of the success mix (my theory is that this makes the government be closer to the people as well as forcing trade since you’re clearly better off working together than trying to navigate international politics alone), but there’s plenty of counter-examples so it’s clearly either not the only requirement or flat-out wrong. I tried reading a book on the topic but then the book doesn’t adequately explain it either ^^ It seems to be an unsolved problem as of yet

    Either way, despite the current government I guess I’m proud of the place I’m from. You get to decide your own life (factors including: people are multilingual, relatively low inequality, euthanasia available (not that I’d currently want to, but self-determination just seems like a good principle that a crazy number of countries don’t yet have)), though iirc the rich are getting richer and both rich and poor citizens are currently voting to widen that gap (as well as other short- and long-term issues, strawman problems… the usual). We’ll see where we stand in 100 years. Maybe I shouldn’t be proud, since all that I’m proud of was built by my forebears (particularly before privatisation, which has its pros but maybe not for every aspect of society) and it’s my generation that has yet to stand the test of time 😅

    aanyway, I didn’t get this part:

    and seem completly bored talking about lol

    Could you elaborate or rephrase?