• 246 Posts
  • 626 Comments
Joined 2 years ago
cake
Cake day: June 12th, 2023

help-circle















  • Civic nationalism, ok fine, ethnic nationalism fuck no, it’s insanity grounded in fiction that devolves into tail-eating fascist bullshit very easily.

    Indigenous nations already are and should remain independent (admittedly our federal government has ignored that frequently throughout their history, but we’ve been wrong about a lot of stuff). I do have some cognitive dissonance around my beliefs that a) race and ethnicity are unscientific social constructs we really shouldn’t get too hung up on b) indigenous nations are sovereign and independent nations defined by a common genetic ancestry and there is a moral imperative to recognize them as such, but I think given the particular history and the fact that we have made treaties and other formal promises we are obligated to stand by it’s a special case.

    Either way, I like and dislike some things about both, but if I’m choosing between DuBois’ racial integration and Garvey’s black separatism, I’ve gotta go with DuBois every day of the week. Ethnostates are bad for everyone, even historically marginalized people, and separatism is no treatment for authoritarianism or fascism because they will come for you eventually when they need fuel to keep their social bonfire going.


  • That’s an accurate summary of history, but I gotta disagree with

    time has proven the wisdom behind it

    Even after we scrapped the articles of confederation and moved halfway towards an actual union of states we had a civil war a few decades later because we were too afraid to confront slave state governments and tell them that shit was unacceptable. And then we did a half-ass job of Reconstruction.

    This country’s best moments imo has been the rare instances we get decent and capable people in the federal government who are able to push progress all the way out into rural backwaters, e.g. New Deal public works programs in the Tennessee valley and west Texas, Brown v the Board and Obergefell v. Hodges setting an enforceable standard for basic human rights even though it made places like Mississippi and Alabama big mad, Great Society programs bringing huge improvements to education and childcare through things like Head Start and the Corporation for Public Broadcasting, etc.

    It’s hard to remember because we haven’t had a good one in about five to six decades, but when the US federal government gets it shit together and stops turning brown kids into skeletons for two seconds it is actually capable of great things.


  • Given the fact that every named person in this article was interviewed for this story I am pretty certain it was their own choice to disclose their names.

    That being said, I definitely see where you’re coming from, but I think there’s need for two kinds of community protectors here - ones that everyone in the neighborhood knows on sight and are comfortable talking to who put their names in news stories and on posts and flyers so community members know who to pass information on to, and volunteers who keep a lower profile so they can do other stuff. This group is the former kind

    [Last name] has been trying to recruit more volunteers for the Pilsen patrol. He’s been posting flyers this week. But [last name] is quick to make clear they are not vigilantes.

    They might step in if they witness someone being assaulted or in danger or some way. But he insists they are not looking to start violence.

    “We’re just eyes and ears in the community,” he said. “We want to help alert.”


  • I said “ok” not perfect or even good. About as well as other governments in the world during the same time periods though.

    Is that what you’re advocating for?

    No, I’m advocating for a strong federal government that’s able to go into Arkansas and force their dipshit state government to desegregate their schools. What are you advocating for? Because to me it just sounds like a bunch of tiny and more easily manipulated ethnostates.