

This is precisely it.
A: several businesses competing to provide the service
This is really the main argument, if two companies supply a widget then they will both keep undercutting each other to gain custom. Hopefully that will come from identified efficiency gains through better production methods or removal of middle management who drain the budget without providing value.
However what is more likely to happen is that quality will decrease, think bulking out chocolate with palm oil, which then depends on the informed customers part to avoid reduced quality and support those that identify real cost savings. But that is unlikely to happen here as everyone jams crappy palm oil in their products and we can’t easily reward those that provide a proper chocolate.
You can see the support for this on the c/buybritish
and c/buyeuropean
groups but it requires real effort, an effort that most people don’t have the time for.
I may misunderstand the situation, so please correct me, but isn’t the issue due to the separation of the energy production from the home suppliers?
The rules as I understand them are that there is a “most favoured nation” rule, so energy production from Octopus (for example) has to go onto the national grid where they are paid for their production, because that’s how you get electricity into homes (unless you want to build our own electricity “alt-net”). Octopus the consumer sales then have to buy the electricity at the wholesale rates which they then sell to you.
Why you can’t get a credit on your account for the excess Octopus are paid for their cheap wind instead of expensive gas, I don’t know but I can only assume its because they aren’t actually the same company. What it also means is that we will never have cheap electricity until we are 100% moved off any and all expensive electricity sources.
What I’m disappointed in as well is that councils can’t get involved with turbines. Any monies generated could be put towards everyone’s council tax, it may help get past NIMBYs if they know they are getting a tax break because of it and it improves energy independence.