A federal judge on Saturday barred the administration of President Donald Trump from deportations under an 18th century law that Trump invoked just hours earlier
James E. Boasberg, chief judge for the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia, said he needed to issue his order immediately because the government was already flying migrants it claimed were newly deportable under Trump’s proclamation to El Salvador and Honduras to be incarcerated there
“I do not believe I can wait any longer and am required to act,” Boasberg said during a Saturday evening hearing in a lawsuit brought by the ACLU and Democracy Forward. “A brief delay in their removal does not cause the government any harm,” he added, noting they remain in government custody but ordering that any planes in the air be turned around
Forgive my ignorance. Please explain. What I remember from reading about this elsewhere yesterday:
it looks like 5 men with tattoos were mistakenly identified as gang members, and started a suit. Sounds good, if they were falsely accused they should be exempt and compensated.
Then the judge makes it a case against all deportation of all people from america; which this article barely mentions in one sentence.
So my questions are
-
whenever i hear about gang members they seem like badguys. Is sending venezuelan gang members from america to venezuela actually bad? Why?
-
is switching the case from the faulty identification of a few to a fight on behalf of all people being deported a strategically sound decision? It feels like now the case has a larger possibility of failing for the 5 misidentified nongangmembers if their case was good and they are truly nongangmembers. Wouldn’t it make more sense to fight All Deportations as it’s own giant case rather than evolve this one about the 5 misidentified people?
-
For those wondering.
50 USC § 21
Whenever there is a declared war between the United States and any foreign nation or governmentLiterally the first words in the law Trump attempted to use to deport these people. Congress has not declared any war, this is literally our Government falling apart at this point. Congress will do nothing to reel this President who violates the laws on a daily basis.
We are never recovering as a Nation from this. This kind of violation of the order of law in our nation will take a century to heal if not more. The United States as it was is gone, full stop.
US 1.0 is over. And now over the next decade we’ll determine which side gets to write up what the US 2.0 will look like
Silly bint probably thinks that if he just posts “I DECLARE THIS IS A WAR” on social media then it’s a declared war.
No he for sure thinks calling something a war makes it one. He thinks shit like the War on Drugs, are actual wars.
He did literally argue that documents are declassified if he thinks they are.
Things is… Documents are only classified due to a presidential order. He can (while president) declassify whatever he wants, whether it’s wise to or not. The issue was that he was no longer president and made no indication that those documents were declassified.
You’re correct, there is an actual procedure that you’re supposed to follow… but iirc, Trump actually stated that the documents just were declassified because he had that thought in his head, while still president, so therefore that counts and its all fine, he can keep them.
The war on Tesla hate.
A formal declaration of war requires congressional approval, as outlined in Article One, Section Eight of the Constitution.
That document? Didn’t you hear it’s null and void now?
They’ve ignored that since WW2. They’ve ignored the “a well regulated Militia” part of the 2nd amendment also.
Like Michael Scott declaring bankruptcy
We are never recovering as a Nation from this. This kind of violation of the order of law in our nation will take a century to heal if not more. The United States as it was is gone, full stop.
Well, that is the goal. I think the goal is to create a (US/global) crisis, which allows the powerful (rich) to step in to reshape the society, to fit their agenda better.
I do not think that the Trump administration is simply incompetent, I think they are having a plan, and are executing it and what we see is part of it.
Isn’t it officially still at war with North Korea?
The US has never officially been at war with North Korea, it was (and still is, I guess) a “police action”. The last time the US officially declared war was WWII.
Every law and statue needs to come with a time limit. And if it’s still useful we can renew it. So many ancient laws still out there that should have been purged long ago
Trump needs to be arrested
ICE needs to be disbanded too
And no “just following orders” defence?
Or something a little more extreme…
I seem to recall how much the radical right thought that offering “helicopter rides” to people they deemed their enemies was the very height of comedy. They even wore t-shirts. I wonder if they think it’s just as hilarious in the case of actual enemies of the state.
It is the Ides of March…
Et tu Vance?
Seriously, how many crimes will he commit before something stops him? Who polices the president? Ohhhhh right, it’s Congress. The courts can check his orders when someone sues, but they don’t charge him with crimes. I guess it could be possible for a blue state to arrest him when he commits a heinous crime within its borders, but I won’t hold my breath
And deported.
I can’t wait for him to invoke the Magna Carta next
After renaming it the MAGA Carta
“Best charter…”
ordering any planes in the air be turned around
They’re out here, plsying games, having carseat temper tantrums with airplanes. While we all burn and choke on soot.
